For my third game I was still Evil to my roommate's Good, but we tried the
Judge scenario this time.  Willow started with the Living Flame.  Drusilla and
Vamp X went for artifacts, Spike went for cards (maybe because he couldn't
move far) and Buffy got the Boots of Running in that corner.  Xander got the
Magik Sword *again*, Vamp X got the Book of Spells, and Drusilla had trouble
getting anything.  Oz turned wolf and chewed on Vamp X a bit, Drusilla finally
got the Arm (not that Good knew this, of course) and Buffy came down to pay
her a visit.  Drusilla used Surprise Attack and Sire a Vampire, out of hope,
and actually rolled the two fangs to sire Buffy in the first attack.

Oops.

Drusilla then skipped over to raise the Judge -- the proximity to that square
was why she'd risked attacking Buffy rather than going straightaway, I knew
Buffy couldn't kill her that fast -- and barely moved again, since I had a
sired vamp to deal with.  Buffy and the Judge got Oz trapped between then and
soon killed him; Vamp X wandered up toward the Initiative and got killed by
Xander while rummaging for Evil cards.  Buffy got Invited and went to get
Xander in his house, but couldn't roll damage for shit.  Really -- 3 rolls,
no damage.  The Judge went up to speed things up but after getting whacked by
the Magik Sword, the Rocket Launcher, and a bit more, was soon down to 5 life
and started running for his life.  Willow got sired by Buffy though and went
to spend her life in the High School since I rolled lots of big flame + 1
little flame.  Spike and Drusilla of course could never move again unless I
got 3 flames, and weren't going to move off their black dots.

You'll note Xander's plight.  Oz is dead, Buffy and Willow are vampires, and
Buffy keeps trying to kill him, although she's surprisingly bad at it.  The
only thing to prevent the end of the world is him.  And his Magik Sword and
high-combat Help cards, of course.  The game turned into a chase -- him
chasing the Judge, Buffy chasing him -- but he managed to catch up and knock
the Judge down to 1 life point.  So close!  But then Buffy caught up to Xander
and knocked him down to 1 life point.

I was actually chicken enough to consider having the Judge run, but my
roommate pointed out that with 5 dice the odds were really on my side, despite
Buffy's experience.  So the Judge attacked and rolled 4 damage, blasting
Xander to ash and dooming the world.

Which makes it 1-2, Good vs. Evil, with the 1 being largely due to Evil
getting caught outside twice.  I've stopped considering ways to make Evil more
powerful.  But it's neat how the game teeters back and forth -- at first I
worried, given the starting cards; then I thought I was on top, especially
with the easy sire of Buffy; then the Judge was on the run, and even Xander by
himself was doing okay.  I suffered from bad rolls later, else the game would
have ended earlier, but got that early ridiculous roll on Buffy, which must
have massively changed the game.